Skip to content
Truesourdough.com Sourdough, made doable
Join the course
Join the course

9 Bakeries Serving the Best Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls in America

One sourdough cinnamon roll in New Jersey gets its rise from a starter said to be 100 years old and born in Greece. I love that a breakfast pastry can carry that much history in every swirl.

Across the United States, bakers are swapping commercial yeast for wild starters in their sweet dough. That swap adds a gentle tang to all the cinnamon and sugar.

Some versions are vegan and gluten-free. Another turns the classic roll into flaky croissant dough.

The bakeries below stretch from a Rhode Island shop that often sells out to a Florida sandwich house where everything starts with sourdough. A few sell rolls in four-packs for pickup.

Others pop up at farmers markets on weekends, which feels like a very good excuse to go shopping.

Hours shift and trays empty fast, so plan ahead. Which swirl deserves your next Saturday morning?

Co-Dough, Newport, Rhode Island

Co-Dough, Newport, Rhode Island
© Co-Dough Bakery

Social media gave these buns a nickname, and Co-Dough wears the word viral proudly. Its sourdough cinnamon buns have pulled curious eaters to Broadway in Newport, and many folks are happy to wait in line for one.

Size is a big part of the appeal here. Reviewers often point to the generous scale of each bun and the heavy layer of icing on top.

Timing matters more than you might expect. The shop opens at 8:30 AM, Wednesday through Sunday, and buns are known to sell out.

My advice is simple: treat this like catching an early ferry. Show up close to opening, and you give yourself the best shot at leaving with a box.

Newport makes a fun setting for a sweet morning. Grab a bun, then walk off a few bites around a town packed with historic streets and ocean views.

Since the shop closes Monday and Tuesday, double-check your travel days. A quick look at the bakery’s current hours can save you from a sad, bun-free drive.

Sharing is a smart strategy with a roll this big. Split one with a friend, and you may have room for a second treat later.

Bring patience along with your appetite. A short wait feels much shorter when cinnamon is involved, and it gives you time to plan your next stop in town.

Address: 95 Broadway, Newport, RI 02840

Peace & Love Sourdough, Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Peace & Love Sourdough, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
© Peace & Love Sourdough

Cardamom rolls with rose icing share the menu here, and that pairing tells you this Milwaukee bakery likes a little adventure. Its classic sourdough cinnamon rolls come in four-packs topped with vanilla icing.

Flour gets serious attention at Peace & Love Sourdough. The bakery uses 100% organic, stone-ground flour and hand-mixes every loaf.

Loaves are the main focus, so think of the rolls as a sweet side quest. Still, a four-pack is handy for a family breakfast or a weekend brunch with friends.

Those cardamom rolls deserve a spot on your radar too. Cardamom brings a floral, slightly citrusy spice that is popular in Scandinavian baking, which feels right at home in Wisconsin.

Plan your visit around the weekend. The Brady Street shop lists hours of 7:30 AM to 4:30 PM on Saturday and Sunday only.

Farmers market fans have another option. The bakery offers pickup at various markets, so check its current list before you head out.

Brady Street is a lively East Side strip, great for strolling after you grab your box. Bring a tote bag, since you might leave with a loaf too.

Buying a four-pack also means planning ahead for leftovers. Warm a roll gently in the oven the next day, and breakfast feels fresh again.

Address: 1101 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202

The Sourdough Society, Jersey City, New Jersey

The Sourdough Society, Jersey City, New Jersey
© Sourdough Society

A starter said to be 100 years old traveled from Greece to Jersey City, and now it helps raise cinnamon rolls. The Sourdough Society calls itself an organic sourdough virtual bakery, and it leans hard on that old culture.

Matcha lovers get a treat here. Cinnamon rolls come plain or matcha-flavored, which gives you an easy way to switch things up.

Organic flour is another point of pride for this bakery. If ingredient lists matter to you, that detail makes these rolls an appealing pick.

Location news needs a careful look before you go. The storefront at 210 Hudson Street temporarily closed, and the bakery announced plans for a new spot in Jersey City Heights.

Because of that move, check the bakery’s own channels for the current pickup address. Opening dates can slip, and nobody wants to stare at a locked door.

Farmers markets offer another route to a roll. The bakery has listed pickup options at local markets, which can be a fun way to shop for the rest of your weekend groceries too.

The virtual bakery setup means ordering ahead may be your best move. Look at the menu online, pick your flavor, and choose a pickup spot that fits your schedule.

I find the starter story charming. A century-old culture feeding a matcha cinnamon roll feels like history meeting a modern cafe menu.

Address: 210 Hudson St, Jersey City, NJ 07302 (former storefront, confirm current location before visiting)

Gulf Coast Sourdough Sandwich House, Tampa, Florida

Gulf Coast Sourdough Sandwich House, Tampa, Florida
© Gulf Coast Sourdough Sandwich House

Sandwiches get top billing in the name, yet the shop calls its sourdough cinnamon rolls our famous. That is a bold claim, and it makes me curious about the dessert case.

Every item on the menu is sourdough-based. Pressed sandwiches, pastries, and those rolls all start from the same fermented foundation.

The cinnamon rolls use a long-fermented sweet dough, cinnamon sugar, and icing. Long fermentation gives a starter more time to build flavor, which is a big reason bakers love the method.

You could easily turn one stop into two meals. Grab a pressed sandwich for lunch, then take a roll home for tomorrow morning.

Hours are friendly to early risers. The shop lists Tuesday through Saturday from 8 AM to 3 PM, plus Sunday from 9 AM to 2 PM.

Mondays are off, so plan your craving around that. Arriving earlier in the day can also help you catch the pastry selection before it shrinks.

Tampa’s Florida Avenue corridor runs through Seminole Heights, an area with plenty of local food spots. A roll in hand makes exploring the neighborhood much sweeter.

Bringing a group? Order a few sandwiches to share and a handful of rolls, and everyone gets a taste of the full sourdough lineup without arguing over the last bite.

Address: 6703 N Florida Ave, Tampa, FL 33604

Third Space Bakery, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Third Space Bakery, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
© Third Space Bakery

Brioche and sourdough rarely share the same sentence, but Third Space Bakery blends them into one cinnamon roll. Its sourdough brioche roll is leavened with a sweet starter, a fun twist on the usual method.

A sweet starter is fed and kept so it suits enriched doughs better. Brioche is rich with butter and eggs, so that pairing makes good baking sense.

Ingredients get thoughtful attention here. The bakery focuses on all-organic grains and local ingredients whenever it can.

Plant-based eaters, take note. Many of the sweet and savory treats are vegan, so mixed groups can usually find something to share.

Since the cinnamon roll is brioche-based, ask staff which items fit your diet. A quick question at the counter beats guessing.

Hours lean toward the morning crowd. The bakery lists Wednesday through Saturday from 8 AM to 2 PM, and Sunday from 9 AM to 2 PM.

Penn Avenue is a long Pittsburgh corridor with lots to explore nearby. Pair your roll with a walk, and you have yourself a lovely weekend plan.

Closing at 2 PM means late sleepers could miss out. Set an alarm, grab a roll, and enjoy the rest of your day feeling very accomplished.

I like a bakery that experiments without losing sight of comfort food. A brioche cinnamon roll raised by sourdough hits both marks.

Address: 5349 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15224

Mrs. Sourdough Organic Bakery, Nolensville, Tennessee

Mrs. Sourdough Organic Bakery, Nolensville, Tennessee
© Mrs. Sourdough Organic Bakery

Four is the magic number at this Tennessee bakery, where cinnamon rolls come boxed as a sourdough four-pack. Mrs. Sourdough Organic Bakery sells its Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls (4-Pack) made with all organic ingredients.

The bakery describes its ingredients as gut-healthy, which matches its strong focus on sourdough. Many fans of fermented bread enjoy that angle, though everyone’s body is different.

Pickup is the way to go here. You can collect orders at the bakery in Nolensville or at the Richland Park Farmers Market in Nashville.

Bakery pickup windows are short, so mark your calendar. Tuesday runs 10 AM to 12 PM, while Wednesday through Friday and Sunday run 8 AM to 12 PM.

Saturday is not listed for bakery pickup. That makes the farmers market option especially handy for Nashville shoppers, so check the bakery’s current market schedule.

A four-pack fits family breakfasts nicely. Kids get their own roll, and the grown-ups do not have to cut anything into tiny, suspicious pieces.

Nolensville sits just south of Nashville, so the drive is easy for many Middle Tennessee folks. Combine your pickup with errands, and the trip feels extra useful.

Leftover rolls reheat well with a few minutes in a low oven. Cover them loosely with foil so the icing does not scorch.

Address: 2000 Oak Trail Dr, Unit C, Nolensville, TN 37135

Sensible Bakery, Long Island City, New York

Sensible Bakery, Long Island City, New York
© Sensible Bakery

Gluten-free bakers have been hard at work in this Queens kitchen since 1992, long before gluten-free aisles took over grocery stores. Sensible Bakery bakes everything in a dedicated gluten-free kitchen.

Its sourdough cinnamon rolls are both vegan and gluten-free. For anyone who has skipped cinnamon rolls for years, that combo feels like a small miracle.

Vanilla frosting tops each roll. The bakery describes them as soft and fluffy, which is no easy trick without wheat or eggs.

A dedicated kitchen matters for people who avoid gluten for medical reasons. Shared kitchens can bring cross-contact risk, so this setup gives many shoppers peace of mind.

Ordering works on a handy schedule. Place your order by 1 PM, and you can pick it up the same day.

Pickup is local, so plan a stop in Long Island City. The bakery sits in a suite on 47th Avenue, so double-check directions before you go.

Planning a party with mixed diets? A batch of these rolls lets everyone at the table share the same treat, which is a pretty sweet win.

Still have specific allergy questions? Contact the bakery directly about other ingredients, since vegan and gluten-free do not cover every allergy.

Address: 30-30 47th Avenue, Suite 160, Long Island City, NY 11101

Knead Bakehouse + Provisions, St. Louis, Missouri

Knead Bakehouse + Provisions, St. Louis, Missouri
© Knead Bakehouse + Provisions

Fourteen years of feedings have gone into the starter at Knead Bakehouse + Provisions. That same culture powers the pastry, breakfast, and lunch menus at this St. Louis spot.

Cinnamon rolls sit right in that lineup. Because the starter runs through the whole menu, the rolls share roots with everything else on the counter.

The bakehouse calls itself a Midwestern sourdough bakery. Its stated mission is helping more people enjoy excellent bread and pastries.

Breakfast and lunch service make this an easy all-day stop. You could start with a cinnamon roll, then stay for a sourdough sandwich if hunger strikes again.

Hours stay consistent across the week, minus Monday. Tuesday through Friday runs 7:30 AM to 2 PM, and weekends run 8 AM to 2 PM.

Early birds have the advantage with that 2 PM close. Arrive in the morning if your heart is set on a roll.

Hampton Avenue runs through south St. Louis, near the St. Louis Hills area. It makes a handy stop before a trip to nearby Francis Park or other south city errands.

Want a fun kitchen fact? A sourdough starter can live for decades if bakers keep feeding it flour and water, so this 14-year-old culture still has plenty of life ahead.

Address: 3467 Hampton Ave, St. Louis, MO 63139

Proof Bread, Mesa, Arizona

Proof Bread, Mesa, Arizona
© Proof Bread

Croissant meets cinnamon roll in the Morning Bun at Proof Bread, and both sides seem pretty happy about it. Cinnamon sugar swirls through flaky laminated dough, giving you layers instead of a classic bready spiral.

Here is the impressive part for bread nerds. Proof’s laminated doughs are leavened only with sourdough starter, with no commercial yeast doing the heavy lifting.

Laminated dough is folded with butter many times to create thin layers. Doing that with a wild starter takes patience, since fermentation moves on its own schedule.

Technically, a Morning Bun is not a traditional cinnamon roll. Still, it scratches the same itch while adding a buttery, pastry-shop crunch.

Arizona fans have options. Proof Bread runs multiple locations across the Phoenix metro area and in Tucson.

The Mesa shop on Main Street is a handy downtown stop. Locations list daily hours of 7 AM to 4 PM, or until they sell out.

That sellout clause matters for pastries with lots of hands-on work. Check the specific shop’s hours before driving across the Valley.

Hot summer mornings make early visits extra smart. Grab your bun before the heat climbs, then enjoy it somewhere shady with a cold drink.

I love ending this list with a roll that bends the rules a bit. Sourdough keeps surprising people, even in pastry cases.

Address: 125 W Main St, Mesa, AZ 85201

Baked it? Tell us how it went

Your email stays private. Tell us your flour and your kitchen temperature if something went sideways — it is usually one of those two.